Defense for Theft and Shoplifting Allegations
A theft accusation can arise from a retail transaction, a borrowed vehicle, an online purchase, workplace property, or a disagreement over money. The label alone does not establish what happened or which offense the evidence can support.
Attorney Jack M. Downie Sr. represents clients facing criminal allegations in Southeast Georgia. Call 912-324-2320 or request a consultation with Downie Law in Vidalia.
Different Theft Charges Require Different Proof
- Theft by taking: O.C.G.A. § 16-8-2 concerns unlawfully taking or appropriating another person's property with the required intent to deprive the owner.
- Theft by shoplifting: O.C.G.A. § 16-8-14 covers specified retail conduct, including concealment and certain price or label changes, when accompanied by the required intent. Leaving the store is not the only conduct addressed by the statute.
- Theft by deception: O.C.G.A. § 16-8-3 concerns obtaining property through qualifying deception with the required intent. Failure to perform promised services, standing alone, is insufficient under the statute's service-promise provision.
- Theft by conversion: O.C.G.A. § 16-8-4 addresses knowingly converting lawfully obtained property or funds to one's own use in violation of an agreement or known legal obligation governing their use or disposition.
- Theft by receiving: O.C.G.A. § 16-8-7 concerns receiving, retaining, or disposing of stolen property that the person knows or should know was stolen, subject to the statute's exception for an intent to restore it to the owner.
The defense must address the specific charge. A payment dispute, possession of an item, or a store report should be examined in context rather than treated as a complete account of the case.
Value, Prior Convictions, and Sentencing
Georgia theft penalties depend on the offense, the property's value and type, prior qualifying convictions, and other statutory circumstances. O.C.G.A. § 16-8-12 governs penalties for several theft offenses; shoplifting has separate provisions in § 16-8-14. A low alleged value does not guarantee misdemeanor treatment in every situation.
Counsel reviews the applicable penalty provision and the evidence supporting valuation before advising about sentencing exposure. A store's or owner's stated amount is part of that review, along with receipts, item descriptions, condition, and other relevant records.
How Downie Law Reviews the Evidence
- Compare the allegation with receipts, bank records, contracts, messages, return records, and account histories.
- Identify available video and witnesses promptly, because recordings and other records may not remain available indefinitely.
- Examine identification, ownership, permission, and the mental state required for the charged offense.
- Review police questioning, searches, and seizure of property or electronic devices.
- Evaluate the available defenses, trial issues, and any lawful resolution supported by the facts and the client's circumstances.
What to Do Before the Consultation
Keep the citation, warrant, indictment, bond paperwork, and hearing notices. Preserve receipts and original communications. Follow court orders and discuss any request to contact the complaining witness, return property, or make payment with counsel first. Do not delete records or ask others to change their accounts.
When contacting the office, identify the county, the exact charge if known, the alleged value, and the next court date. Do not send detailed confidential information through a public inquiry form before the firm confirms it can assist.
Speak With a Southeast Georgia Theft Defense Attorney
Downie Law maintains one office at 510 Maple Dr., Vidalia, Georgia 30474. See our criminal-defense services and regional service area.
Call 912-324-2320 or request a consultation. Office hours are Monday through Thursday, 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.; closed Friday through Sunday. Consultation availability and fees depend on the matter.